[en] | Symphony No. 9 (Schubert)

For a long time, the symphony was believed to be a work of Schubert’s last year, 1828. It was true that, in the last months of his life, he did start drafting a symphony – but this was the work in D major now accepted as Symphony No. 10, which has been realized for performance by Brian Newbould.^[4] It is now known that sketches for the ‘Great’ were largely composed in the summer of 1825^[5][6] and that it was indeed the work to which Schubert was referring in a letter of March, 1824 when he said he was preparing himself to write ‘a grand symphony’ (originally listed as Gmunden–Gastein symphony, D 849, in the Deutsch Catalogue). By the spring or summer of 1826, it was completely scored and in October, Schubert, who was unable to pay for a performance, sent it to the Gesellschaft der Musikfreunde with a dedication. In response, they gave him a small payment, arranged for the copying of the orchestral parts, and at some point in the latter half of 1827, gave the work an unofficial perfunctory run-through (the exact date and the conductor are unknown) – though it was set aside as too long and difficult for the amateur orchestra of the conservatory.^[7]

A recent hypothesis suggests that the symphony may have received its first performance on 12 March 1829 in a Concert Spirituel at the Landständischer Saal of the Palais Niederösterreich in Vienna.^[8] The evidence for this hypothesis is slender, however, and it contradicts contemporary sources which prove that Schubert’s Symphony No. 6 (also in C major) was performed at this instance.^[9] In 1836, Schubert’s brother Ferdinand attempted to have the final movement performed, yet there is no evidence that a public performance ever took place.^[9]

In 1838, ten years after Schubert’s death, Robert Schumann visited Vienna and was shown the manuscript of the symphony at the Gesellschaft der Musikfreunde by Ferdinand Schubert. He took a copy that Ferdinand had given him back to Leipzig, where the entire work was performed publicly for the first time by Felix Mendelssohn at the Leipzig Gewandhaus on 21 March 1839.^[10] Schumann celebrated the event in the Neue Zeitschrift für Musik with an ecstatic article in which, in a phrase destined to become famous, he hailed the symphony for its ‘heavenly length’.^[11]

The symphony, however, was found to be very difficult for orchestras of the day because of its extremely lengthy woodwind and string parts. When Mendelssohn took the symphony to Paris in 1842 and London in 1844, orchestras flatly refused to play it; in London, the violinists are reputed to have collapsed in laughter when rehearsing the second subject of the finale.^[12]

There continues to be long-standing controversy regarding the numbering of this symphony, with some scholars (usually German) numbering it as Symphony No. 7. The most recent version of the Deutsch catalogue (the standard catalogue of Schubert’s works, compiled by Otto Erich Deutsch) lists it as No. 8, while most English-speaking scholars number it as the 9th.

Following the standard symphonic form, there are four movements:

I. Andante – Allegro ma non troppo – Più moto

The first movement begins with an extensive introduction with its own miniaturised exposition, development and recapitulation. The opening theme is used in a modified form as secondary subject matter in the main section of the movement. The rest of the movement is in sonata form with two periods for each theme and several transition themes and extra material. The opening theme of the introduction is restated in the coda (b. 570) before the final cadences.